Is Kasab in Paradise?


According to the lascivious promises made in the Islamic scriptures to the martyrs, Ajmal Kasab must now be in the blissful paradise reclining on “a raised throne woven with gold and precious stones,” wearing “silken garments,” “bunches of fruits hanging within reach,” jugs of wine at hand, served by “Houris with wide, lovely eyes (as wives for the pious), like preserved pearls, a reward for deeds that they used to do”…

Probably, Kasab was not aware of such heavenly rewards when he agreed to hold up the Kalashnikov against the teeming multitude in an Indian railway station.  Somebody with nothing more than primary education and abject poverty as the only resources, Kasab could not have been aware of even the voluptuous aspects of Islamic jihad.  When he was questioned by the police soon after his arrest, Kasab, lying in a hospital bed, said clearly that he had done it for money and nothing else.  He said his father must have been paid lakhs of rupees.  It is that earthly paradise that Kasab was interested in.  And that too, for his family, rather than for himself.  He knew he would die.

He also knew he would die a “martyr.”  So it is not unlikely that he was unaware of the paradise that awaited him in the life hereafter.  His masters must have conjured up a vivid picture of that paradise in the process of brainwashing him.  (One such picture, provided in wikiislam, is what I have given as a link above.  Such paradise cannot be anything but tempting for a young man deprived of even the money to buy a new pair of dress for Eid.)

It is more likely that Kasab died in despair, without even the kind of wisdom that one acquires in solitude or at least the terrifying realisation of one’s depravity.  According to a front page report in The Hindu [Nov 22] which quoted a police official who was present during the execution, Kasab probably did not even understand exactly what was going on.  “It’s also possible he’d ceased to care,” the report quotes.

Perhaps his mind had become numb.  Unable to feel, think or react.  A state that may be called “spiritual aridity,” a state that results from inner emptiness.

Will any god reward such emptiness, aridity, with paradise?  I don’t know.  My knowledge about the supernatural is zilch.

But I know that the kind of thinking that underlies the creation of people like Kasab should change if life on this earth (which can be a paradise too!) is to have some semblance of peace.

Tariq Ali, writer and film-maker, suggests the following: “We are in desperate need of an Islamic Reformation that sweeps away the crazed conservatism and backwardness of the fundamentalists but, more than that, opens up the world of Islam to new ideas…. This would necessitate a rigid separation of state and mosque; the dissolution of the clergy; the assertion by Muslim intellectuals of their right to interpret the texts that are the collective property of Islamic culture as a whole; the freedom to think freely and rationally and the freedom of imagination.” [The Clash of Fundamentalism: Crusades, Jihads and Modernity, Rupa & Co, 2003, pp: 338-9. Emphasis added.]

Alas, a similar suggestion can be made with respect to quite many religions today!


About matheikal

My more regular blog can be accessed at
This entry was posted in religion and tagged , , . Bookmark the permalink.

11 Responses to Is Kasab in Paradise?

  1. Raghuram Ekambaram says:

    Kasab might have known that he would die. Perhaps. But, I am quite sure he would not have imagined how he would die – in a hail of bullets or at at the end of a long rope. This matters. The first is a biological survival thing. The second one is a cultural memetic thing. My question,what did Kasab think about the fate of his co-actors? Did they reach a higher plane of bliss? Was he jealous of them? I am sure he would have commented somewhere or the other. But, I am not motivated enough to find out.

    By the way, please do not use triple negatives – “So it is not unlikely that he was unaware of the paradise that awaited him in the life hereafter.” It took me a while to figure this one out 🙂 🙂 🙂


    • matheikal says:

      Raghuram, I was aware of the miasma that this sentence would create. I wanted to emphasise that miasmic nature of the hereafter. Kasab’s paradise too is to be seen in that haze only!

      • Raghuram Ekambaram says:

        But, you addressed only the trivial part of my comment, Matheikal. What about the more significant (at least from my perspective) part?

        As far as I am concerned the after life is not at all miasmic. It is most definitive and vivid. It is non-existent! How is that for adding to the miasma 😉


      • matheikal says:

        True, life after death is not miasmic. There’s no life after death. For you and for me. But for others who are spending an entire life on the beautiful planet called the Earth, destroying it, polluting it, violating it, raping it… there is a paradise to be gained. That’s the pie in the sky 🙂

  2. pa1more says:

    i may be very naive to comment on religion beliefs..
    but as observed and read little ..Most of the religions preach about heavens and afterlife.The motive behind that was to make people do good karma and lead a peacefull life in this life but we have misinterpreted it to make our afterlife easier .What about this life !!??..

    To add i agree with last para of blog Tariq Ali..


  3. You gave the whole ‘Kasab story’ a different point view. I wonder if during the whole tenure anybody would have tried to figure out what was going on in his mind!!

    Liked it!

  4. Pallavi says:

    Hi Matheikal, thanks for visiting my blog 🙂

    This is a well written article that dwells on an important topic. I have myself often wondered the same thing and even spoke to a few of my Muslim friends. Their viewpoint was this, ” people such as Kasab are brainwashed and in a way lose their sense of direction in life. The Quran doesn’t say anything about killing innocent people and acquiring jannat”. Tariq has rightly said that a revolution is required to bring about a change.

  5. iku2e says:

    i like the last part of your post..some people believe that they are only allowed in heaven and it means than other religious people will go to hell 🙂 I have been encountered with such friends and i have completely avoided them and neglected them when it reached the level of forcing me to follow their so called … fact we all should be human beings first 🙂 you rightly said.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s